Components and physical properties of hydrogels modulate inflammatory response and cartilage repair

Collagen and hyaluronic acid are commonly applied in cartilage tissue engineering, yet there has been limited investigation into their inflammatory response, a crucial factor in articular cartilage repair. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of components and physical properties of hydrogels on inflammatory response and cartilage repair. Three kinds of hydrogels with comparable storage modulus at low frequencies were designed and fabricated, namely methacrylic anhydride modified hyaluronic acid hydrogel (HAMA), methacrylic anhydride modified type I collagen hydrogel (CMA) and unmodified type I collagen hydrogel (Col). HAMA hydrogel was unfavorable for adhesion and spreading of BMSCs. Furthermore, HAMA hydrogel stimulated rapid migration and pro-inflammatory M1 polarization of macrophages, leading to persistent and intense inflammation, which was unfavorable for cartilage repair. CMA and Col hydrogels possessed the same component and facilitated the adhesion, spreading and proliferation of BMSCs. Compared with CMA hydrogel, Col hydrogel induced rapid migration and moderate M1 polarization of macrophages at the early stage of injury, which was mainly influenced by its fast dissolution rate, small pore size fiber network structure and rapid stress relaxation. In addition, phenotype of macrophages timely transformed to anti-inflammatory M2 due to the property of collagen component, which shortened the duration of inflammation and enhanced cartilage repair. The results indicated that moderate macrophage activation modulated by hydrogel components and physical properties was critical in modulating inflammation and cartilage regeneration.